Thread: worlds 2008
View Single Post
  #320 (permalink)   IP: 203.114.148.2
Old 09-01-08, 07:03 AM
amc32's Avatar
amc32 amc32 is offline
Big Fish
Registered User
 
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: Wellington, NZ
Posts: 143
Rep Power: 0
amc32 is an unknown quantity at this point
Quote:
Originally Posted by Carol Rose View Post
Open divisions created in masters and juniors to allow countries (such as USA) who didn't have enough women to field (ummm pool?) a womens team in those divisions - to give women a chance to compete at WC...
...sport is for the athletes.
ok ok i'm in a grumpy mood this morning i admit it

BUT i think that if sport is for ATHLETES then restricting all grades to individual sexes is a better way to encourage growth in all divisions

what incentive is there for masters or junior women to swell their ranks if those that are really enthusiastic can always just go and play in the men's team?
ditto the masters/junior men - not enough players to fill a roster? go out and find some more men; don't just burgle the female playing stocks of it's top players

all that ends up happening with 'open' teams is that, essentially, club-strength teams arrive at international competitions. athletes who have trained hard don't want to play enfeebled opposition.

how about developing playing stocks domestically to fill a team rather than watering down competition levels internationally


oh, and i'm partly grumpy cos i realised that Jersey have not shown any intent to enter a team in any division in durban
Reply With Quote